Think Freely Media presents Common Sense with Paul Jacob

Local government is hard. In rural areas, it can be like organizing an ongoing bake-sale. In metropolitan areas, it’s more like running a small country.

Today’s big metropolitan governments tend to be run by un-term-limited oligarchs, so of course corruption is endemic. When there’s little competition for power and scant oversight, then the “above-board deals” become, de facto, insider deals.

And we wind up paying more in salaries and benefits for government workers than anything else. Recently, George Will off-handedly noted that in California “80 cents of every government dollar goes for government employees’ pay and benefits.”

Is that “too much”? Had we limited government, we would still expect salaries to make up a huge chunk of government. But since transfer payments are part and parcel of so much of modern governance, the fact that employee compensation packages are actually crowding out other line items should give us more than pause.

Truth is, though, it needn’t be hard to tell who is over- or under-paid, according to economist Arnold Kling:

If you do not have enough sanitation workers because you cannot fill job openings at the current level of pay, then those government workers are underpaid.

On the other hand, if you do not have enough sanitation workers because your budget is busted by the ones you have, then those government workers are overpaid.

Take that notion to your next local government board meeting. Big or small.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.

By: Redactor


  1. Dagney says:

    There’s a refrain by the elites that if they have to cut their budgets, they’ll be laying off emergency personnel and “we can’t have that!” This drives me crazy because everyone else seems to accept this premise as true. The emergency people, the teachers, the road workers, in other words, the people who actually DO something are the LAST people that should be considered for layoffs. I want to see responsible people in government actually look at the fraud, waste, and abuse going on FIRST! Then they can start cutting all the cubicle jockies in all the redundant agencies. Then, we can talk about trimming other areas.

  2. John Ken says:

    Why is it that it’s always the other guy that makes too much money?

  3. Some Links says:

    […] Jacob offers common sense – both his own and that of Arnold Kling – to explain how to determine if government […]

  4. N. Joseph Potts says:

    It was bloated governmental payrolls that brought Argentina (once an advanced, prosperous country) to its knees (and keeps it there). Rome, too. And communist Cuba, where a work-free government job is known as a botella.

    The US is heading straight down that hole. Ineluctably, I fear.

  5. […] talked a lot about how this has contributed to the current out-of-control spending at federal, state, and even local government […]

Leave a Reply to John Ken Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2020 Common Sense with Paul Jacob, All Rights Reserved. Back to top