Think Freely Media presents Common Sense with Paul Jacob

Some folks wait till the last moment to decide how to vote. And when indifference was the mental state right before the decision, we can’t help but wonder what moved the person from indecision to selection. A coin toss?

Or something more insidious?

This kind of worry lies behind a mini-controversy over a CNN News feature. For the 2008 presidential campaign CNN gathered 32 undecided voters and gave them knobs to turn as they listened to candidates’ speeches. Turn the knob one way for approval, the opposite for disapproval. A computer averaged out the responses, and graphed them in real time underneath the TV image of the candidate speaking.

Such graphic elements of newscasts have been called “worms.”

Psychologists have studied this sort of thing, and suspect that the mere presentation of this average approval rating amounts to “spin.”

And, as such, constitutes undue influence of a small group, perhaps easily manipulable, over a large group of voters.

British psychologists studying CNN-like worms say they accumulated data of measurable signs of influence. “The responses of a small group of individuals could, via the worm, influence millions of voters,” the scientists write. They also declare this effect “not conducive to a healthy democracy.”

Yes, yes, but “peer pressure” has been a known element of democracy for some time.

Only the worms are new.

And, in their context, they provide more information. As with speech we may not like, more and different worm varieties (on different networks, perhaps) is undoubtedly the best response.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.

By: Redactor

4 Comments

  1. Drik says:

    An informed populace is capable of their own government per Jefferson.
    A misinformed populace, ie one where most or all of the news is slanted to reflect the goals of the current adminsitration, is capable of being nudge/shoved off in a direction where they make bad decisions and decide things that are in the interests of a select few.
    We CAN handle the truth.

  2. […] How the Worm Turns Some folks wait till the last moment to decide how to vote. And when indifference was the mental state right before the decision, we can’t help but wonder what moved the person from indecision to selection. A coin toss? http://thisiscommonsense.com/?p=6344 […]

  3. Bob Schmidt says:

    “We’re all voting for Goldwater” I told the voters in my 1st door-to-door campaign. It was in 3 innercity Chicago precincts that allegedly were stolen by Kennedy. I caught the Dem precinct captain by surprise. Goldwater tripled Nixon’s vote and doubled Ike’s vote. I thought if he was doing so well in the inner city, he would certainly win nationwide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2017 Common Sense with Paul Jacob, All Rights Reserved. Back to top