Think Freely Media presents Common Sense with Paul Jacob

The Venezuela Chaos

government, bathtub, Venezuela, illustration

I have friends who call themselves anarchists. Their theory? Government is always merely an open conspiracy of some to live at the expense of others.

Republicanism, on the other hand, proposes that if we limit government, we can hone it down to the level where there is no conspiracy, and everything the government does can plausibly help everybody.

Not just a few insiders.

Socialism is the opposite notion. Socialists seek to grow government so far that it “naturally” serves everybody, not only the few. It’s all about “equality,” you see.

Here’s what we know for sure: socialism, when really tried, is so awful that it makes anarchy-as-chaos sound good.

The latest socialist horror is Venezuela, which is getting worse every day. Now hospitals place newborns in cardboard boxes. There are no other supplies.

But that’s not all. The special program for feeding everybody? It’s now mainly for feeding just those close to the government — precisely as my anarchist friends say all government is:

Six months after the creation of the Local Committees of Supply and Production (Clap) that is designed to “distribute food directly to the people,” the government has decided to change its approach by threatening those using the program.

The Venezuelan government announced that it will suspend delivery of food packages to those who criticize its policies.

Are socialist out to prove anarchists right?

I bet most of my readers still put some hope in limiting government to serve all. Venezuelan socialism demonstrates how badly the opposite idea is, showing us that serving everybody by total government just decays into the folks allied closely with government warring against everybody else . . . who starve in plain sight.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.

 

Ask the next question.

Questions Answered:

What is the difference between a republic and a socialist state?

What do anarchists think of government?

What happens when government tries to do everything for everybody?

The Next Question:

How do we convince well-meaning socialists that total government cannot work for the benefit of everybody? (Since the examples of the USSR, Communist China, and Venezuela haven’t worked so far.)


Printable PDF

government, bathtub, Venezuela, illustration

 

By: CS Admin

2 Comments

  1. John F. Brennan says:

    Involuntary socialism must eventually self-destruct as it is a utopian construct which is contrary to human nature.  The free market economy is anarchy, hopefully administered under the least intrusive rule of law possible. 
    It is interesting the freer the market is, the closer it is to anarchy, the more efficient it is and better it works while the more controlled a command economy becomes the lees it can do, eventually leading to collapse. That IS the lesson of history. 

  2. “The old principle: who does not work shall not eat, has been replaced with a new one: who does not obey shall not eat.” —Leon Trotsky, The Revolution Betrayed, ch 11 Whither the Soviet Union? § 2 The Struggle of the Bureaucracy with the Class Enemy.

    Most who support an extensive state either are implicitly sure that it shall never fall in opposing hands (perhaps as a result of demographics ), or regard the potential benefits to be so great that they outweigh the risks.

    Their sense of the risks is impaired by a refusal to look at the failures. For example, few on the political left now pay any more attention to Venezuela than they are compelled to pay, by virtue either of living there, or of being put-on-the-spot in discussion. In the latter case, expect words to be strung together into formulæ that will sound plausible to those on the left, though they will be logically incoherent.

    And their sense of the potential benefits is fatally flawed by a nearly complete ignorance of the problem of economic calculation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


© 2016 Common Sense with Paul Jacob, All Rights Reserved. Back to top